Quick Luddite Notes

🐧 Do people at Asahi Linux understand how open-source works?

The short version: Asahi Linux changed the license from MIT to GPL.

The long version:

We take great pride in our work, and have always done all of our development in the open. We communicate with our users, our followers and our financial sponsors as transparently as is humanly possible. Our finances are in the open, our development branches are in the open, and we report our progress regularly and candidly in the open. Our IRC channels and Matrix rooms are safe spaces, open to anyone with even a passing interest in Asahi Linux or hacking on Apple Silicon.

We do all of this because we firmly believe in Free and Open Source Software, not just as a means to an end but as the end in and of itself. The modern digital world is only possible because of the Free Software movement, and it is more important now than it ever has been that we do all we can to protect the Free Software ecosystem and uphold the ideals upon which it is built.

It may surprise some to learn that WINE was originally made available under the MIT licence. The 90s and 2000s were a very different time in the Free Software ecosystem, and permissively licenced projects were viewed by tech companies as free real estate to pilfer and exploit. WINE was not immune to this, and many monetised proprietary forks of WINE were marketed and sold by various bad actors. The WINE development team grew increasingly concerned that these proprietary forks, while well within their rights to exist, would eventually cause so much fragmentation in the ecosystem that WINE itself would become unviable. In 2002, WINE was relicenced under the LGPL to prevent further proprietary forks from being created, and to encourage direct upstream contribution.

When Asahi Linux was first started, it was with the intent that we develop a Free Software ecosystem for the Apple Silicon platform. To facilitate and encourage the participation of our friends at the BSDs and other Free Software operating systems, we endeavoured to licence as much of our code as possible under the permissive MIT licence.

Unfortunately, this is no longer viable. The malicious practices of the 90s and 2000s have reared their ugly heads once again, this time driven in large part by both the insatiable appetite of frontier AI labs for high-quality training data, and militant animosity toward the Free Software community.

Some time ago, we were made aware of multiple attempts to exploit our permissive licensing to hijack our work, with a direct view to replacing the project and aggressively monetising Linux on Apple Silicon. In some extreme cases, in-development feature code was being lifted straight out of our personal forks and published without attribution or lazily rewritten with LLM assistance to obfuscate its origin. The MIT licence explicitly allows this, and has no carveouts to protect against bad faith actors.

As such, we made the difficult decision to begin the process of transitioning all of our repositories to the GNU General Public License version 2 or later. Going forward all Asahi Linux code will be licenced under strong copyleft licences only. Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it.

This is completely retarded, although so typical for the Linux ecosystem.

You see, the members of RMS’ (Richard Matthew Stallman) sect strongly believe that the GNU General Public License (GPL) is the only path to freedom. “It’s free, it’s open source, but if you add your own shit to it, you need to give it back.” The MIT License, the 2-Clause BSD License, and the 3-Clause BSD License are “dirty” because they basically say, “Do whatever you want with this code, just leave my copyright notice attached and don't sue me if it breaks.” Due to its brevity, the MIT license is preferred by adepts of TRUE FREEDOM to the legal prose of the BSD licenses.

Yes, that means people can take your already open-sourced code, modify it, build a proprietary product, and never give anything back. Why does this diminish your ego, you twat? You should have kept everything close-source if you’re such a snowflake!

The dogma says that the mandate to give back “to the community” made Linux the number one open-source OS. This is simply not true. Practically all the money was put into Linux because of the mono-mania that spread into the industry, which started with a strong initial momentum coming at the right moment. Was it Linus Torvalds’ charm? I doubt it. Was it the trouble the BSDs had with the assholes from the Unix System Laboratories (USL), which sued BSDi and Berkeley in April 1992? Heck, yeah! Meanwhile, Slackware 1.0 released in July 1993, and everyone was mesmerized by the new horizon of opportunities. As a side note, Slackware’s installer was then much more practical and helpful than what Arch has today.

If the US-centric industry weren’t so stupidly concerned with lawsuits (which had ended) and more with common sense, they would have avoided this one-size-fits-all approach.

Instead, everything is Linux nowadays, from embedded systems to entertainment systems and Android (which is screwed not by the kernel, but by everything else).

And Linux isn’t doing great, with commercial support available from the predatory Red Hat (IBM) and the stupid Canonical (mimicking Red Hat) to the moribund SUSE. Hundreds of Linux distros have died in the past 30 years (I tried most of them!). Today, there’s a mania to derive from Arch and create useless crap (on my oldest laptop, Cachy, or anything using Cachy’s kernel, runs slower than anything else, with the exception of Windows 11). Then everything will become immutable, just like ChromeOS, Android, and iOS.

The GPL cannot save Linux from its imminent fall. It’s only a matter of time.

But retards are concerned that releasing code under the MIT license allows LLMs to steal from them!