Quick Luddite Notes

🍎🍌🍍 The sinister “95% of people cannot solve this” math joke

It's an old one:

Google will tell you that the values depend on what types of numbers are allowed, because this viral meme is actually a famous mathematical prank that is easy with negative numbers or decimals, but requires advanced number theory to solve with positive whole numbers.

🍆 If negative numbers are allowed, the smallest solution is the following one (any permutation is also a solution):
• Apple = 11
• Banana = 4
• Pineapple = -1

So, (11, 4, -1). Then, (-5, 9, 11) is another solution.

ℹ️ On a random forum I found 144 solutions (permutations included) in the integer range [-100, 100].

🍆 If the numbers only need to be positive (not whole numbers), you can pick 1 for both the Apple and Banana and solve a simple quadratic equation for the Pineapple:
• Apple = 1
• Banana = 1
• Pineapple = (7 + sqrt(65))/2

🍆 In the original version of this meme—created as a joke to parody clickbait math puzzles—it specifically asks for positive whole values. The smallest positive whole numbers that work are 80 to 81 digits long:
• Apple: 154476802108746166441951315019919837485664325669565431700026634898253202035277999
• Banana: 36875131794129999827197811565225474825492979968971970996283137471637224634055579
• Pineapple: 4373612677928697257861252602371390152816537558161613618621437993378423467772036

ℹ️ Clearing the denominators turns the equation into a three-variable cubic equation:
a³ + b³ + c³ - 3(a²b + ab² + b²c + bc² + c²a + ca²) - 5abc = 0

ℹ️ PMATH 340 has this problem at page 11, with the solution at page 191: