Varoufakis, the eternal contrarian. Interviewed by Paddy O’Connell for the BBC on Nov. 20: “You should not have left” | Yanis Varoufakis on EU deal and why UK “should not” rejoin (22 minutes).

I selected a few ideas from those expressed by Yanis. I replaced a couple of “which” with “that”—because grammar.


00:02:14 It is my strong suspicion that Andy Burnam is going to honor his aspiration to see Britain return to the EU in his lifetime, more in the breach than in the observance. After all, he’s shown himself to be a master at selling the sizzle when he’s not prepared to, you know, share the stake. So I think that, you know, these are small moves that he makes in exactly the same way that he’s done small moves when it comes to VAT and electricity and so on, in order not to make the big moves. This is my assessment of Andy Burnam’s intentions.


00:02:55 Look, it’s important. I mean, if you are a food exporter and you’re facing this mountain range of red tape, it’s great. Also, you know, when it comes to perhaps closer alignment between the City of London, the financial sector, and Europe, those are all features that should have been there in the original Brexit deal. But the big question about the customs union, the single market, I think, you know, he’s having us having this discussion now about tuition fees and this, that, and the other, so as not to have the serious conversation.


00:03:50 I mean, it’s a strange character because I was essentially at war with Brussels, but I also campaigned in this country against Brexit because I thought that the costs would be too high. But of course, those costs now are sunk. They’ve already been paid. So the question is, what does Britain have to get out of returning to the single market, the customs union, and so on? So that’s another conversation altogether.


00:07:41 Continental Europe is stagnating. You see, this is not 2015, 2016. The Europe, the European Union that Britain would be rejoining—where it to rejoin the European Union—is not the European Union from which it exited. Back then, I was campaigning against Brexit because investment was much higher in continental Europe. You could say, and convincingly, I could convince myself, that Europe was a source of growth and an engine of growth for Britain. Now you can’t say that. Britain has been actually growing very tepidly, but more faster and, in qualitative terms, better than either France or Germany.


00:09:07 And if I may add one vignette here, you know one of the good things that Andy Burnham did—and I’m a critic of Andy Burnham—was that he removed VAT from electricity bills. He could not have done that had he been in the European Union. These are significant differences. You would not get back your rebates. You would probably have to commit to entering the Euro and that would be a catastrophe for Britain.


00:09:57 You would have some [exemptions]. You would probably still be exempt from Schengen. You would have to make some kind of airy-fairy commitment to the Euro that you would never fulfill, like Sweden, like Poland. But you never get the rebates that Margaret Thatcher secured. And you will never be able to restrict freedom of movement, which I don’t think is a problem. But you would have a serious problem with AI, for instance. You would have to accept rules and regulations by the European Union that would kill off the growth spurts that AI is having in Britain, and that is a major cost. I don’t think it’s worth it.


00:10:36 You should not have left because the costs were too large, but you’ve paid those costs. Now you shouldn’t rejoin because again, on average, the net effect is going to be negative.


00:10:50 I don’t think you should [rejoin]. I think that you have a much, much bigger problem in this country—and I say this as an Anglophile, as somebody who really loves this country. There’s so much money in the City of London that is not being invested productively in manufacturing and even AI as much as it should do. And this is the conversation you should be having. You know, spending another five years talking about the single market and the customs union, I think, is a waste of energy.


00:11:36 There’s going to be a huge debate in France about its contributions to the European Union. But you see, we could not have avoided that. The Brits couldn’t have avoided it. The Greeks couldn’t avoid it because Europe is a large block. It is utterly dependent on the United States economy and has been since 1944, even before the end of the Second World War. And you know, in the first two decades after the war, in the 1950s and the 1960s, we had the golden age of capitalism that was completely dependent on the capacity of the United States to recycle its surpluses to Europe, the Marshall Aid Plan, the cheap money that was coming in the form of credit from the United States. And the United States had a plan for Europe. I mean, you see, we Europeans, especially on the continent, would like to fool ourselves into thinking that the European Union was a great European idea. It wasn’t. It was an American idea that was implemented through diplomacy of the highest order by the United States. You know, they banged heads together, and they got the French and the Germans to agree to this European Union.


00:12:58 So there were differences among the Europeans. They weren’t being told that if they want the Marshall Plan, they will have to accept a European Union between France and Germany. They were not told to accept Britain in there because, after all, you know, Winston Churchill talked about the United States of Europe as long as Britain is not part of it.


00:13:31 They had far less agency than they would have liked to because, you know, without the United States bringing together France and Germany and through Marshall Aid, lifting all the boats from the bottom of a muddy lake after the 1940s, you know, France could not have developed.


00:13:59 I’m sad. Not about Greece. I am sad about Germany because Germany is deindustrializing today. And I used to say that even when I was finance minister, I was saying to my German colleagues, “What you’re doing to my country is not simply unethical. It is self-defeating because the austerity you’re imposing upon us and that you’re taking to the Irish, to the Portuguese, to the Italians, to the French, and then to yourselves is going to make one thing absolutely certain. Investment is going to drop to zero in Germany, and you’re going to have a process of deindustrialization.” And I’m sad as a true Europeanist. I’m sad for the whole of Europe because you know this combination of austerity for the many, including in Germany, not just in Greece. So I’m not angry with anyone. I’m not an angry person. I’m very sad for the European Union that has wasted its energies and its capacity to invest in its future.


00:15:24 I gave a speech in Berlin in June of 2015, and I called upon Angela Merkel to do what the Americans had done when they started when they sent their Secretary of State Burns to give the speech of hope. And I said unless we bind together in Europe and unless we avoid a competitive race to the bottom through austerity, then we are going to lose our capacity to be heard around the world.


00:16:11 And I’m going to be blunt. Europe has a choice to make between two stark options: creative federation, a democratic federation, or disband. Unfortunately, we’re doing neither. We’re taking the third option of doing nothing. Of simply waiting until stagnation makes us so weak and so geopolitically relevant that nobody will care about what Europe wants. And I’m saying this with pain in my heart as a Europeanist. I believe in a European federation. If we don’t want that, then we shouldn’t have federated our money because think about it. What we did was absolutely mad. We federated our money. We have the same currency, and we don’t have a treasury that can back up this monetary union. And we have, you know, 27, 28, 29 treasuries that have to bail out their banking systems when they’re in trouble without the equivalent of the Bank of England to have that back. It is madness what we did. And you know, there was a British economist, Nicholas Kaldor, who in 1970 published in the New Statesman a prescient article in which he said, he warned Europeans—Kaldor was a Cambridge professor, and he was a great Europeanist. He wasn’t a Brexiteer. And he had warned Europeans. He said, “Look, if you want to federate, if you want to create a united Europe, don’t make the mistake of federating your money, having a monetary union as a first step, because that is going to toxify politics”—as it did with the euro crisis. And then, you know, if I go to my people in Greece or any politician, not just me, and say, “Let’s federate Europe,” you know what is going to happen? The equivalent of a reform agenda is going to be thrown at us. What, more Europe? Nobody wants more Europe. And I regret this as a Europeanist.